CityToasty'S Tavern
1258 S Shelby St · 40203 · Food Service
Most recent inspection April 3, 2026 — 194 days ago. Down 1 points from the previous inspection. On average this location is inspected about every 171 days.
Inspection types on record: Regular (2).
Why this grade is A
A grades go to establishments scoring 90 or above — inspectors found no major food-safety problems. The inspection score was 95 out of 100.
No itemized violations were published for the most recent inspection, so the score is the only detail on file.
Inspection summary
Toasty'S Tavern has 2 health inspections on record with Louisville, with scores ranging from 95 to 96. The latest inspection on April 3, 2026 recorded 0 itemized violations. The average current score among 60 other establishments in ZIP 40203 is 98, so this location scores lower than its neighborhood average.
Inspection history
- A · 95
April 3, 2026
Regular
- A · 96
October 14, 2025
Regular
Other inspections near Toasty'S Tavern
- Wright Place Day Care600 S 18th StA · 98
- R & B Mobile Bartending1812 W Muhammad Ali BlvdA · 99
- Engelhard Elementary School1004 S 1st StA · 97
- KFC Y052-0231911 W BroadwayA · 99
- Portland Promise Center1831 Baird StA · 98
- Khayat Oil1812 W Muhammad Ali BlvdA · 100
- Vegkentucky1812 W Muhammad Ali BlvdA · 100
- River Oaks Health And Rehab920 S 4th StA · 99
- Luna Sol Pizzeria213 W Ormsby AveA · 96
- Salvation Army Center Of Hope911 S Brook StA · 99
Source: Louisville Metro open data. Grades shown as “derived” are calculated from the published score when the record has no official letter grade.